Your local bakery, pizza shop, brunch & dinner stop, cozy cafe with patio and full bar! 

Our Story 



Burning Mountain Pizza is a warm and comfortable cafe, bakery, pizza and sub shop that serves fantastic espresso drinks as well as a great variety of healthy and tasty breakfast, lunch and dinner options.  Our pizzas are all hand-tossed with home-made sauces and quality fresh ingredients. We are famous for our house-made bagels, cinnamon buns, scones, quiche, fresh breads and cream puffs! Our menu is filled with nourishing and delicious food options.


We strive to provide food as it should be; our concept of great food is fresh, simple, and gratifying.

Always made from scratch, with the highest-quality, local when available ingredients and love.

Connecting people and the community around us. 

Our story begins in 2016, when we, sisters, Jen and Cori Gerstner, turned our dreams, goals and family friendship into a business relationship and opened Burning Mountain Bakery and Deli on Mail St. in the historic downtown of New Castle. We were voted as a Local's Choice Award Winner, and this original business quickly won the hearts and appetites of the local townspeople and surrounding communities by fulfilling the diverse needs of the local area. The bakery's superior delights and 'taste-bomb' menu items quickly made it a neighborhood fixture. 

Today, we are now located in Silt, Colorado.

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs 

We have over 30 years of restaurant experience and a commitment to our community! We believe it's about finding balance, making quality, accessible food, while also giving back to our neighbors and the environment. 


Private Events


Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs has been serving up great dishes and bakery delights since 2016. Choosing to have us cater with our delicious scratch-cooked house-baked food will assure a great event!

Our menu has something for everyone, including tasty appetizers, salads, sub sandwiches, hot speciality subs, pizzas and desserts!

We are proud of our reputation for great food and friendly service.

Choose Burning Mountain Pizza for your next business meeting, company picnic, family celebration or more... Let us do all the work for you! 


1817 Medicine Bow Court

Silt, Colorado 81652

Monday - Closed

Tuesday  -  Sunday     10:30 AM – 8 PM    


Lunch and Dinner

Full Bakery, Espresso Bar & Cocktail  Bar


Tel: 970-876-2201

Email: burningmountainpizza@gmail.com